An airline which argued that a passenger’s headfirst fall down icy, snow-covered steps as he left an aircraft did not amount to an accident has been ordered to pay him more than £100,000 in compensation.
Essex businessman Carmelo Labbadia, 77, broke his right shoulder and pelvis when he fell down the steps of an Alitalia plane parked at Milan airport in February 2015.
As a result, he has been left with lasting pain and a limp which means he is unable to maintain his beloved sports cars, his home and his garden without help and has had to take on staff to assist him.
Not careful enough
Although Alitalia accepted the fall had happened it argued that ice wasn’t to blame and suggested that Mr Labbadia had not been careful enough as he left the plane.
At the High Court, Judge Margaret Obi did not agree: “In my judgement, Mr Labbadia was not the author of his own misfortune,” she said. “He did nothing other than descend the disembarkation steps on the instructions of the airline.”
She awarded him £106,344 in damages including provision for help with household tasks and £5,000 towards the upkeep of his classic cars.
Mr Labbadia sued Alitalia arguing it was liable to pay him damages under the 1999 Montreal Convention which governs international air travel.
The airline argued that the incident did not amount to an accident because the presence of snow was not an ‘unexpected event’.
Its lawyers claimed: “Meteorological conditions cannot be considered an unusual or unexpected event in air travel.”
But the court heard that, against standard practices at the airport, the stairs had not been cleared of snow by the time the first passenger left the aircraft, causing compacted snow to form, on which Mr Labbadia ultimately slipped.
Mr Labbadia’s barrister Mr Lionel Stride also said that snow in Milan in February was not normal. “Mr Labbadia had never encountered snow when arriving in Milan,” he said.
Although flying is an extremely safe method of transport, there are still things that can go wrong like trips and slips on stairs or in the aisle, suffering an illness like food poisoning, being injured by luggage falling out of overhead storage lockers or being hurt during a bad landing or turbulence.
There are a number of straightforward ways you can seek to claim compensation:
For more information about this area of the law, and to see if you might be able to seek compensation, please contact Richard Green or any member of Wards Solicitors’ specialist Accident and Injury team.
Wards Solicitors remains open for business and we are taking on new cases. We are available for video call and telephone meetings but cannot currently offer face to face meetings with clients except in some specific emergency situations and at court hearings.
How to get in touch:
A list of our 12 branches is available here. Our telephones lines are operating as normal behind closed doors.
Important Warning: Cyber-crime is very common including email interception. We will never tell you of changes to our bank details by email. Please be aware that we accept no responsibility if you transfer money to a bank account which is not ours. If you receive an email giving our bank account details, please telephone us immediately without replying to the email or sending money.